We see our clients as naturally creative, resourceful, and whole. But do we extend that same respect and curiosity to our fellow coaches?
Lately, something in social media discussions among professional coaches has given me pause.
Even among highly trained, credentialed coaches, curiosity about another person's perspective can sometimes get lost when we disagree about coaching philosophy.
And I can't help but notice the irony.
As professional coaches, we're trained to approach our clients with curiosity rather than judgment. To listen without making assumptions. To honor their perspectives rather than impose our own.
But are we practicing what we preach with each other?
I've watched discussions among experienced coaches where the focus shifts from an exchange of perspectives to a debate over who's right.
One coach shares an opinion about coaching. Another disagrees.
Nothing wrong with that. Healthy disagreement is essential to the evolution of our profession.
But sometimes disagreement becomes a declaration of what's right and wrong. An attempt to correct another coach or explain why their approach isn't legitimate coaching, often in the name of helpfulness.
And what's often missing?
Genuine curiosity.
What if our understanding of coaching, no matter how experienced or credentialed we are, is incomplete?
I don't believe most coaches intend to be condescending. Many genuinely believe they're protecting the integrity of coaching and upholding professional standards.
But as we often remind our leadership clients, our intentions don't determine our impact.
Our intent may be to preserve the integrity of coaching, but our impact may leave fellow coaches feeling small, judged, or patronized.
When leaders tell us, "That's not what I meant," we invite them to consider how their words actually landed.
Yet when another coach experiences our words as dismissive or condescending, are we equally willing to examine our impact?
I learned about the concept of intellectual humility from two highly accomplished neuroscientists.
Despite their expertise and extensive research, they emphasized the importance of remaining open to one simple possibility:
We could be wrong.
That's not a weakness. It's what makes learning, discovery, and progress possible.
If even accomplished neuroscientists recognize that their understanding is continually evolving, shouldn't we coaches be willing to question our own assumptions?
Intellectual humility doesn't mean abandoning our convictions or professional standards.
It means holding our convictions while remaining curious about what we might not yet understand.
We believe our clients are naturally creative, resourceful, and whole. We trust their capacity for insight and don't approach them as people who need fixing.
But when a fellow coach expresses an unconventional perspective, do we see a thoughtful professional whose experiences have led them to a different conclusion?
Or someone who needs correcting?
Of course, our fellow coaches aren't our coaching clients. A social media discussion isn't a coaching session, nor should it be.
We're entitled to our opinions, our convictions, and our interpretations of professional standards. And we're certainly not obligated to approach every disagreement with coaching questions.
But here's what I'm curious about:
Are curiosity, humility, and respect simply skills we demonstrate when we're coaching, or are they values we aspire to embody beyond the coaching relationship?
And let's be clear: curiosity doesn't require agreement.
We can genuinely seek to understand another coach's perspective and still disagree with their conclusions. Intellectual humility doesn't mean every interpretation of coaching is equally valid, nor does respecting another professional mean abandoning our own standards.
The question isn't whether we're willing to disagree. It's whether we're willing to understand before we dismiss.
Our profession needs vigorous debate, intellectual diversity, and the courage to challenge established thinking.
Not every uncomfortable disagreement is evidence of disrespect. But how we challenge one another still matters.
There's a difference between challenging an idea and diminishing the person expressing it.
Between sharing expertise and asserting superiority.
Between believing in coaching standards and believing your way is the only way.
We can have strong convictions without being closed-minded. We can challenge without being condescending. And we can disagree without assuming we have nothing to learn from the other person.
Shouldn't our training make us particularly skilled at doing exactly that?
I care deeply about the coaching profession and the mission of the ICF. As President-Elect of ICF Los Angeles, I see my leadership role as an opportunity not only to uphold our professional standards, but also to encourage the curiosity, humility, and openness that make our profession stronger. And that includes being willing to question my own assumptions.
It's one thing to demonstrate curiosity, empathy, and nonjudgment within the coaching relationship.
It's another to bring those same qualities into conversations where our own deeply held beliefs are being challenged.
Especially when the person disagreeing with us is another coach.
And especially when we're convinced we're right.
If we believe every client deserves to be met with curiosity rather than judgment, why would our fellow coaches deserve anything less?
Perhaps one of the greatest demonstrations of coaching mastery isn't how we show up for our clients.
It's how we show up for one another.